The Paradox of Self-Reliance and Surrender

I’ve written quite a bit about good and evil, and one of the things I continue to wrestle with is the idea of labeling anything God has created as inherently evil, bad, or wrong.

I struggle with the thought that something originating from God, something created through God, could somehow be inherently evil. I find myself drawing a distinction between what God creates and what we, through our own free will, choose to create.

Perhaps evil isn’t necessarily something God created. Perhaps it is something that becomes possible through our ability to choose. The ability to love also gives us the ability to hate. The ability to build gives us the ability to destroy. The ability to serve gives us the ability to exploit. The same freedom that allows us to express the best of our humanity also allows us to express the worst.

And perhaps that is part of the extraordinary responsibility that comes with being human.

But there is another aspect of my journey that has caused me to reconsider how I understand good, evil, faith, and our relationship with God.

There was a period in my life when I intentionally separated myself from God. I became extremely self-reliant. I went from living with the belief that God controlled my life to believing that I alone controlled my life.

Looking back, I could easily characterize that period as a mistake, a departure from faith, or even a sinful way of living. But I wonder whether doing so would overlook an important part of what I needed to learn.

I needed to discover personal responsibility. I needed to understand that I couldn’t simply sit back, attribute everything to God’s will, and expect life to unfold according to my wishes. I needed to understand that my decisions mattered, my actions mattered, and that I had a responsibility to participate in creating the life I wanted to live.

I needed to discover the importance of works.

Not works as a replacement for faith, but works as an expression of what I believe.

And that brings me to what I consider one of the most important lessons of my life: self-responsibility and surrender are not opposing principles. They are complementary necessities.

For a long time, I understood these concepts almost as competing ideas. Either I took control, or I surrendered control. Either I relied on myself, or I relied on God.

But perhaps I was looking at it incorrectly.

Perhaps God doesn’t ask us to abandon our responsibility. Perhaps He asks us to exercise it while recognizing that we are not the ultimate authority over everything.

We are responsible for our choices, our attitudes, our efforts, our character, and the way we treat others. We are responsible for doing the work that is ours to do. But we must also recognize that there are things beyond our control, things we cannot force, predict, or manipulate.

That is where surrender becomes necessary.

What Running Taught Me About God

There was a time when I was a long-distance runner. Out of that experience came one of the most valuable lessons I’ve ever learned: we are capable of going far beyond what our minds initially tell us is possible.

I remember being at mile two and wondering how in the world I was going to make it to mile five.

At mile ten, I felt like I was literally dying.

At mile twenty, I couldn’t imagine being in more pain.

And yet, I continued.

I stopped running at mile twenty-five, thirty, or forty. On two occasions, I made it to forty-four miles.

Think about that for a moment.

At mile two, my mind couldn’t envision mile five. At mile ten, it was telling me I couldn’t continue. At mile twenty, every signal seemed to suggest that I had reached my limit.

But those limits weren’t necessarily the limits of my actual capabilities. They were often the limits of what my mind could comprehend at that particular moment.

I learned that discomfort doesn’t always mean stop. I learned that the mind can convince us that something is impossible long before we have actually discovered what is possible.

And perhaps there is a spiritual lesson in that experience as well.

How often do we allow our minds to establish limits on what we can become? How often do we confuse our current understanding with the full extent of our potential?

How often do we surrender to fear, doubt, insecurity, and the limitations of our own imagination?

We say we can’t, when what we really mean is that we don’t yet know how.

We say it is impossible when what we really mean is that we cannot currently see the path.

Of course, running also taught me something else. There is a difference between knowing when to push through discomfort and knowing when to stop because continuing would cause harm. Wisdom is learning to recognize the difference.

But the larger lesson remains: we are often capable of much more than we believe.

Perhaps Both Paths Were Necessary

I sometimes wonder whether my period of extreme self-reliance was not simply a departure from God, but an important part of my journey toward understanding Him.

I needed to experience what it meant to believe that everything depended on me. I needed to experience the responsibility, the pressure, the independence, and even the limitations of that way of thinking.

Because eventually, I began to recognize something.

Being responsible for my life doesn’t mean being responsible for everything that happens in my life.

Having the ability to influence my circumstances doesn’t mean having the power to control every outcome.

Having the strength to accomplish great things doesn’t mean I am the source of all strength.

And being capable of standing on my own doesn’t mean I was ever meant to walk alone.

Perhaps I needed to discover my own strength before I could properly appreciate the source of strength.

Perhaps I needed to understand the importance of action before I could understand the importance of surrender.

And perhaps I needed to experience the limitations of self-reliance before I could appreciate the freedom that comes with faith.

There is something beautifully paradoxical about this.

Faith without personal responsibility can become an excuse for inaction. We pray for opportunities but never pursue them. We ask God to change our circumstances but refuse to change our behavior. We surrender our responsibilities under the appearance of surrendering to God.

On the other hand, personal responsibility without faith can become an exhausting attempt to control everything. We begin believing that every outcome rests entirely on our shoulders. We become attached to results, consumed by expectations, and frustrated by everything that doesn’t go according to our plans.

One can leave us passive. The other can leave us exhausted.

But together, they offer something much more meaningful.

Work as though your choices matter. Have faith as though the outcome doesn’t rest entirely on you.

Do what you can. Become who you are capable of becoming. Take responsibility for what is yours to change. And surrender what was never yours to control.

The Balance of Doing and Being

I think this is where my understanding of God continues to evolve.

Perhaps the objective was never to become less capable, less independent, or less responsible in order to become more faithful.

Perhaps it was to become more capable while remaining humble. More responsible while remaining surrendered. More empowered while recognizing that I am part of something infinitely greater than myself.

Jesus spoke about faith, but He also spoke about action. He taught us to love, forgive, serve, give, and treat others as we would want to be treated. These are not passive instructions. They require participation. They require decisions. They require effort.

And yet, He also taught surrender. He demonstrated humility, trust, and submission to the Father’s will.

There is a lesson in holding both.

Maybe the journey isn’t about choosing between God and ourselves. Maybe it is about discovering how to live responsibly without making ourselves the center of everything.

I don’t have to abandon my ability to think, decide, work, create, and accomplish things to have faith in God.

And I don’t have to believe I control everything to take responsibility for something.

Perhaps my journey through independence ultimately brought me closer to understanding dependence on God, not as helplessness, but as a conscious recognition that my abilities, opportunities, and very existence are part of something greater.

I still have to run my race. I still have to take the steps. I still have to do the work.

But I don’t have to believe I created the road, control the weather, or determine every mile ahead.

Maybe faith is not about refusing to take control of the things we can control. Maybe it is about accepting responsibility for those things while surrendering our attachment to the things we cannot.

And perhaps that is where the real transformation happens.

Not in becoming powerless before God, but in learning how to exercise our power with wisdom, humility, love, and purpose.

Not in abandoning ourselves, but in discovering who we were meant to become.

Perhaps I had to learn how to walk on my own before I could fully appreciate what it meant to walk with God.

Leave a Reply

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

Sacred Sobriety: A Path for the Soul

Scriptural wisdom and daily devotions for those thriving in sober living and the Crucified Christian Life

Jimmy Perez

Student of the Human Condition

Yvonne M Morgan

Christian author, blogger and speaker

The Christian Kitchen Table

Your morning stop for Christian News, Devotionals, Bible Studies, and more.

The Agapegeek Blog

ADVANCED BIBLE STUDY! Using the Bible to Understand the Bible!

Touching the Sunrise

Because we all need to know we're LOVED.

Becoming Christians

Discover what the Bible Says

Women's Ministry Tips and Ideas

Everything You Need to Lead with Confidence—Tips, Tools & Women’s Ministry Resources Just for You

# Food for Thought

A bible verse a day for meditation

The Devotional Guy™

Growing Closer to Jesus

Irene Fes Network

Encourage. Elevate. Inspire Transformation.

Fathers Heart Ministry

What ELSE Could POSSIBLY go RIGHT?

Transformation Bible Studies

Our Lord lives! Our Lord reigns!

Bible Study Deep Dive

Learn about religions here

2023 Bible Studies

For Just As the Days of Noah

The Berean Heart: Hank's Bible Study Resources

Search the Scriptures. Love with all your heart.

Bible Study For You

Student of the Human Condition

Northwestern Publishing House

God's Word for my Life

Laura Bon

Inspiring the world